How to Stop Apple Mail From Overriding Your Email Signature Font

Setup Guides · Published 2026-11-15 · 4 min read · Email Signature Editorial

Apple Mail automatically strips custom signature typography unless you uncheck one hidden setting. Here is the complete macOS setup checklist.

The one checkbox that breaks Apple Mail signatures

By default, Apple Mail enables an option labeled Always match my default message font inside the Signatures preferences panel. When checked, macOS strips out your signature's font sizes, colors, and alignment as soon as you compose a new email.

Step-by-step installation on macOS Mail

Use this sequence to keep your formatting locked in:

  • Copy your formatted signature using Copy signature in the editor.
  • Open Apple Mail and press Cmd+, (or Mail → Settings) and switch to the Signatures tab.
  • Select your email account, click the + button, and paste into the right-hand preview pane.
  • Uncheck Always match my default message font below the preview pane.
  • Close Settings and open a new compose window to verify links and spacing.